Ndara’s battle for actors’ rights touches on an age-old struggle

13 October 2019

Tyler Perry is proof that focus on self-growth can help break cycle of exploitation

Actress Vatiswa Ndara must really be commended for her courage to stand up to employers, or should we say exploiters, in the arts and entertainment industry.

Her open letter, while cathartic perhaps for her, quickly caught fire. Mara Louw, a delightful and self-respect­ing actor, told Sowetan: “Our industry is so cruel and rotten. There is a lot of ex­ploitation in the industry but actors are afraid to speak out because you will be blacklisted… I have spoken against ex­ploitation and have been blacklisted. But still, I won’t take peanuts.”

Let me be frank. While I sympathise with Ndara and Louw, their call is un­likely to result in measurable material changes in how the sector operates. One of the positives from Ndara’s letter is that it has forced society to pause and reflect on practises in the sector. This is not only overdue but constitutes progress.

Production companies will take a fresh look at themselves and want to avoid be­ing where the Fergusons are this week­end. In this sense, some actors will ben­efit. It will be hard for anybody – two or five years from today – to quantify this progress.

Is there exploitation in the sector? No doubt. Are public expressions of disen­chantment helpful? To a point. The nub of the problem is how we arrive at what constitutes “fair value”. When you negoti­ate your pay, as an actor, what do you use that objectively determines that elusive mark of the value you contribute? How much of that is delusion? There are no clear answers both in South Africa and around the globe.

To make a general point, we are un­likely to find many people who are happy with their salaries. Take the police, nurs­es, teachers, prosecutors, accountants or even MBA graduates. Even chief execu­tives of South African banks, who earn more than R40m per year, including bo­nuses, remain focused on how to improve their own salaries. Standard Bank paid executives large sums of money then pro­ceeded to retrench poorly paid staff and closed down some branches when it was possible to keep them without running the company down. Why?

The leadership is focused on maxim­ising returns on investment – the same thing done by every self-respecting com­pany.

Yes, rapid technological advancement and innovation are changing how we live and do business. But at the heart of this spectre is corporate greed and social con­tradictions that have been around for long. It is the same thing that sees the Fergusons focused on who to pay less so that they too can retain a bit more fat for their lives of luxe.

The point is that what Ndara is raising is not an issue for the entertainment and art sector – it is a general employer and employee issue that has been around for as long as people have worked. It is the same issues that made Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels plead in 1848: “Workers of the world, unite!” For, this exploitation was as palpable then as it is plain today.

The socialists have attempted to come up with alternatives to capitalist greed, but, hello Communist Nzimande, we are here now!

While I think it is admirable for Ndara to name and shame these exploiters, we must never believe that Minister of Arts Nathi Mthethwa will provide a meas­urable, enforceable solution to this age-old saga.

Actors must be encouraged to learn how to negotiate good contracts for them­selves but also, when paid, how to use their funds responsibly. It is the height of folly to live a flashy, red-carpet life of expensive clothes worn for cameras once and then be buried like a pauper months, if not a few years, later.

Importantly, though, all of us, especial­ly actors, musicians and athletes (gener­ally defined), ought constantly to focus on self-growth. The Fergusons were once plain actors – but today run a successful production company.

Many of us limit ourselves to perpet­ual employment when we can, through tears and toil, become employers later in our lives. Not every actor must become a production company owner. Far from it. Each must work on their own strengths and talents. Caiphus Semenya, that great South African, will be teaching young musicians. Good show.

Tyler Perry unveiled one of the biggest film studios in the US early this week. Years ago, Perry was broke as he tried to make his entry into the world of theatre – a move that made him homeless. But he was possessed of a never-say-die spirit. Today, he is not simply one of the richest men in the US, he is an actor, a writer, a producer, a director and much more.

He has taken the time to invest in him­self. He paid attention to his own pro­gress. He doesn’t act because he has a gig – but acts because he wants to. He could have limited himself simply to acting. And we thank God that his life is a pub­lic master class for our actors.

And so, while it is unlikely that Ndara’s letter will eradicate exploitation of actors, it is important she raised the concerns.

Equally important is the fact that we must learn that those who become future employers didn’t start off as employers– and the actors of today can take certain actions that will ensure that they too, like Perry, will in the future accept acting roles only when they want to.


Latest News

Most Read Posts

Sponsored Content

Sunday World Notifications Would you like to receive notifications on latest updates? No Yes