School principals play vital role in teacher development, Western Cape study finds

Teachers are required to take part in regular professional development activities to keep their skills up to date.

These can include personal study, belonging to professional learning communities, school-initiated workshops, mentorship circles and programmes facilitated by external service providers.

The South African Council for Educators endorses most of the courses and the teachers earn points for completing them.

Advertisement

Many teachers see this continuous professional teacher development as an unnecessary addition to their challenges. They might be dealing with overcrowded classrooms, ill-disciplined learners and heavy workloads (teaching and administration).

Encouraging teachers to do it anyway is one of the responsibilities of school principals.

Heads of schools can identify gaps in their staff’s development and create an environment in which teachers are motivated and enabled to grow. Empowered teachers are a starting point for quality education.

As a group of education researchers, my colleagues and I are interested in teachers’ perceptions and experiences of the principal’s role as leader in supporting their development. We did a qualitative case study involving six teachers from two secondary schools in the Western Cape. It’s common for qualitative studies to have a small number of participants, enabling deeper engagement.

From what they told us, we noted three themes:

• They felt life-long learning was important in their profession;

• Some school principals supported them to attend activities related to content knowledge; and

• Some principals supported teachers in developing their classroom management skills.

We suggest all principals acknowledge and value the roles they play as leaders and create an environment for authentic growth and development of teachers.

Deep dive into teachers’ worlds

For this study, we took an interpretive approach to delve deep into the realities of the research participants, rather than scratching the surface with numbers, reports and statistics.

We conducted semi-structured interviews with teachers who each had more than three years’ teaching experience. This design allowed for flexibility and spontaneity of responses.

Both schools in the study were public schools in the Western Cape Metropole Central Education District. One was in quintile 1 (a division of schools serving the country’s poorest communities) and the other in quintile 5 (serving the wealthiest communities). We chose teachers in these quintiles to establish from their responses whether principals’ leadership might differ according to the school’s resources.

Three important themes emerged from the findings:

  1. Significance of continuous professional development

Teachers at both schools felt that development was crucial for achieving quality teaching and learning experiences in the classroom. Teachers felt it also allowed them to grow as leaders in their own capacities and be effective in a dynamic and diverse school context. They viewed life-long learning as essential because they are required to adapt to the changing nature of the learner population.

As one teacher put it: “The learners of five years ago are not the same learners that we are teaching now.”

Teachers also viewed professional development as important to stay up to date with policy changes and pedagogical content knowledge updates. A participating teacher, who was close to retirement age, highlighted its importance particularly for novice teachers, to enhance skills such as lesson planning, preparation and management of classrooms.

Although teachers generally felt that the teaching was more important than the professional development, some believed the latter was an essential component of their growth as classroom managers and leaders. A participating teacher added that it had the potential to strengthen relationships between principals and their staff.

  1. Principal’s role in supporting teaching content

We found no evidence that principals had a direct influence on their staff’s pedagogical content knowledge (that is, subject matter and how it’s taught). But in the quintile 5 school, it appeared that the principal had an indirect influence.

This was through supporting and encouraging senior staff to arrange development sessions on specific subjects. The principal made provision for teachers to attend the sessions, which subject advisers and departmental heads led.

Teachers at the quintile 1 school felt that support from their principal as instructional leader was non-existent.

They also felt that attending Western Cape Education Department workshops was more of a tick-box exercise than development taking place. These teachers had no faith in their principal or heads of department to guide and lead them in professional development or even to create professional development space for themselves.

  1. Support offered by the principal for effective classroom management

Classroom management is a challenge for teachers in the public-school context. This is for several reasons, such as a lack of parental involvement and accountability; overcrowded classrooms; and learner behaviour, often labelled as “disruptive” and “ill-disciplined” when they struggle to understand pedagogical content. Some learners may have learning challenges that are undiagnosed.

Classroom management is also lesson planning, assessment and creating an environment for learning and teaching.

Teachers at the quintile 1 school reported that they did not receive support from their principal to enhance their classroom management skills or learn how to handle disruptive behaviour.

At the quintile 5 school, the teachers said there was a code of conduct that all learners and parents had to agree to and if learners stepped out of line, they would face consequences.

We concluded that the principal helped teachers to deal with disruptive behaviour.

Why principals’ support matters

Continuous professional teacher development is not efficient when it’s merely a compliance exercise. It should be a response to teachers’ needs. If the education system is to improve, parents, education officials and policymakers should care about how teachers are supported and by whom.

It is clear from the findings that there is a measure of support from principals in the teaching and learning aspect of the teachers’ work. But it’s limited at the quintile 1 (under-resourced) school, where it is most needed.

We call on principals to identify professional learning needs, involve teachers in development decisions, create opportunities for training and strengthen collaboration with departmental heads and subject advisers so that professional development initiatives do not merely become tick-box exercises.

• Esau is a lecturer in the Faculty of Education at Cape Peninsula University of Technology and served as the faculty’s learning and teaching coordinator.

This article first appeared in The Conversation

  • Teachers in South Africa must regularly engage in professional development activities, endorsed by the South African Council for Educators, to earn points and maintain their skills.
  • A qualitative study of six experienced teachers from two Western Cape secondary schools (quintiles 1 and 5) identified three themes: the importance of lifelong learning, some principals’ support for content knowledge development, and some support for classroom management skills.
  • Teachers at both schools agreed that continuous professional development is vital for quality teaching, leadership growth, and adapting to diverse learners and policy changes.
  • Principals in the quintile 5 (resource-rich) school indirectly supported pedagogical content knowledge development and assisted with classroom management through enforcement of a code of conduct, while the quintile 1 (under-resourced) school principals provided little support in these areas.
  • The study recommends principals actively identify staff development needs, involve teachers in decisions, provide training opportunities, and collaborate with department heads and advisers to prevent professional development from becoming a mere compliance exercise.
🎧 Listen to this article

Teachers are required to take part in regular professional development activities to keep their skills up to date.

These can include personal study, belonging to professional learning communities, school-initiated workshops, mentorship circles and programmes facilitated by external service providers.

The South African Council for Educators endorses most of the courses and the teachers earn points for completing them.

Many teachers see this continuous professional teacher development as an unnecessary addition to their challenges. They might be dealing with overcrowded classrooms, ill-disciplined learners and heavy workloads (teaching and administration).

Encouraging teachers to do it anyway is one of the responsibilities of school principals.

Heads of schools can identify gaps in their staff’s development and create an environment in which teachers are motivated and enabled to grow. Empowered teachers are a starting point for quality education.

As a group of education researchers, my colleagues and I are interested in teachers’ perceptions and experiences of the principal’s role as leader in supporting their development. We did a qualitative case study involving six teachers from two secondary schools in the Western Cape. It’s common for qualitative studies to have a small number of participants, enabling deeper engagement.

From what they told us, we noted three themes:

• They felt life-long learning was important in their profession;

• Some school principals supported them to attend activities related to content knowledge; and

• Some principals supported teachers in developing their classroom management skills.

We suggest all principals acknowledge and value the roles they play as leaders and create an environment for authentic growth and development of teachers.

For this study, we took an interpretive approach to delve deep into the realities of the research participants, rather than scratching the surface with numbers, reports and statistics.

We conducted semi-structured interviews with teachers who each had more than three years’ teaching experience. This design allowed for flexibility and spontaneity of responses.

Both schools in the study were public schools in the Western Cape Metropole Central Education District. One was in quintile 1 (a division of schools serving the country’s poorest communities) and the other in quintile 5 (serving the wealthiest communities). We chose teachers in these quintiles to establish from their responses whether principals’ leadership might differ according to the school’s resources.

  1. Significance of continuous professional development

Teachers at both schools felt that development was crucial for achieving quality teaching and learning experiences in the classroom. Teachers felt it also allowed them to grow as leaders in their own capacities and be effective in a dynamic and diverse school context. They viewed life-long learning as essential because they are required to adapt to the changing nature of the learner population.

As one teacher put it: “The learners of five years ago are not the same learners that we are teaching now.”

Teachers also viewed professional development as important to stay up to date with policy changes and pedagogical content knowledge updates. A participating teacher, who was close to retirement age, highlighted its importance particularly for novice teachers, to enhance skills such as lesson planning, preparation and management of classrooms.

Although teachers generally felt that the teaching was more important than the professional development, some believed the latter was an essential component of their growth as classroom managers and leaders. A participating teacher added that it had the potential to strengthen relationships between principals and their staff.

  1. Principal’s role in supporting teaching content

We found no evidence that principals had a direct influence on their staff’s pedagogical content knowledge (that is, subject matter and how it’s taught). But in the quintile 5 school, it appeared that the principal had an indirect influence.

This was through supporting and encouraging senior staff to arrange development sessions on specific subjects. The principal made provision for teachers to attend the sessions, which subject advisers and departmental heads led.

Teachers at the quintile 1 school felt that support from their principal as instructional leader was non-existent.

They also felt that attending Western Cape Education Department workshops was more of a tick-box exercise than development taking place. These teachers had no faith in their principal or heads of department to guide and lead them in professional development or even to create professional development space for themselves.

  1. Support offered by the principal for effective classroom management

Classroom management is a challenge for teachers in the public-school context. This is for several reasons, such as a lack of parental involvement and accountability; overcrowded classrooms; and learner behaviour, often labelled as “disruptive” and “ill-disciplined” when they struggle to understand pedagogical content. Some learners may have learning challenges that are undiagnosed.

Classroom management is also lesson planning, assessment and creating an environment for learning and teaching.

Teachers at the quintile 1 school reported that they did not receive support from their principal to enhance their classroom management skills or learn how to handle disruptive behaviour.

At the quintile 5 school, the teachers said there was a code of conduct that all learners and parents had to agree to and if learners stepped out of line, they would face consequences.

We concluded that the principal helped teachers to deal with disruptive behaviour.

Continuous professional teacher development is not efficient when it’s merely a compliance exercise. It should be a response to teachers’ needs. If the education system is to improve, parents, education officials and policymakers should care about how teachers are supported and by whom.

It is clear from the findings that there is a measure of support from principals in the teaching and learning aspect of the teachers’ work. But it’s limited at the quintile 1 (under-resourced) school, where it is most needed.

We call on principals to identify professional learning needs, involve teachers in development decisions, create opportunities for training and strengthen collaboration with departmental heads and subject advisers so that professional development initiatives do not merely become tick-box exercises.

• Esau is a lecturer in the Faculty of Education at Cape Peninsula University of Technology and served as the faculty’s learning and teaching coordinator.

This article first appeared in The Conversation

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.